What to Ask Before Outsourcing Your Accounting in New York?

For most New York business owners, the first thing they consider when outsourcing their accounting is the potential cost savings, but they also have many other important questions in mind. They ask questions like: Can an outsourced firm truly understand my unique business model? How will they manage my finances as we scale? Who ensures we get customized support, not just a one-size-fits-all solution? It’s not about finding a cheaper option; it’s about whether they can trust the partnership to align with their specific goals and challenges.

In this blog, we will provide a comprehensive checklist of questions to ask when vetting firms, showing you how to get the right accounting outsourcing partner who can provide truly customized services that align with your specific goals and challenges.

Outsourcing Done Right!

Get Streamlined Processes, Expert Support, and Financial Clarity.

Explore More

How much will outsourcing accounting cost, and will it actually save money in NYC?

The cost of accounting outsourcing services depends on the scope of work, the provider’s expertise, and whether the work is done on a project-based or ongoing basis.

That said, hiring a W-2 accountant in NYC runs about $36 an hour, or $75K a year. Compare that to a 1099 contractor in Dallas who can come in around $19 an hour.

This is a substantial saving that accounts for more than just salaries. Businesses also avoid costs linked to recruitment, training, health benefits, paid leave, and office space. For startups and SMEs, these reductions free up significant working capital while still ensuring accurate and compliant financial reporting.

Will outsourced accountants work with our software and tech stack?

Yes, outsourced accountants typically work with a wide range of accounting software and technology stacks used by their clients. Skilled virtual accountants are proficient in working with platforms such as QuickBooks Online, Xero, NetSuite, Dynamics 365 Business Central, Zoho Books, and others.

Additionally, many outsourced providers use advanced tools and cloud-based systems to improve accuracy, automation, and real-time reporting. They collaborate using communication and project management tools aligned with your tech stack to deliver smooth financial management without disrupting your workflows.

Hire a Dedicated Accountant Who:

Maintains Accurate Financial Records and Balances Books

Quick Start within 48 Hours

What about the quality of service, will an outside accountant be as accurate and reliable as in-house staff?

“In a survey of over 257 NYC companies, 26% use a hybrid of internal and outsourced accounting, while another 19% have fully adopted the outsourcing model.”

With the right partner, outsourced accounting can match or even exceed the accuracy of an in-house team. Reputable firms employ multi-tier review systems, internal controls, and reconciliation protocols that reduce the risk of errors. They also rely on cloud-based tools that create audit trails and enforce compliance checks automatically.

Accuracy is further strengthened by the diversity of expertise. While an in-house team may consist of one or two individuals, an outsourced service often includes bookkeepers, senior accountants, AP/AR specialists, and CFO-level advisors. This layered structure provides oversight at multiple levels. Many NYC businesses found that outsourcing brings more reliability because the process doesn’t rely on the availability or knowledge of a single staff member.

Do they understand our industry and the local business environment?

Yes, if you choose a firm with proven industry experience. Many outsourcing providers focus on sectors like real estate, hospitality, healthcare, construction, and e-commerce, tailoring compliance and reporting support to each. For New York businesses, this extends beyond generic accounting into local compliance, including:

• New York State and city corporate income tax with unique apportionment rules for multistate businesses.
• Sales and use tax compliance, including vendor collection requirements and exemption certificates.
• Payroll compliance with state withholding, NYS-45 filings, and the New York Paid family leave program.
• Industry-specific regulations such as union payroll reporting in construction, rent-stabilization and DHCR filings in real estate, tipped wage accounting in hospitality, and inventory tax compliance in retail.

How does an outsourced accountant ensure data security when automating accounting tasks?

Reliable accounting outsourcing firms implement multiple layers of security both technical and procedural, to ensure that sensitive information remains protected while automation improves efficiency.

• Encrypted Data Transfers: All financial data moving between your systems and theirs is encrypted using advanced protocols (like SSL/TLS and AES-256).
• Role-Based Access Control: Automated workflows are set up so that only authorized personnel can access specific data.
• Secure Cloud Platforms: Use of automation tools and accounting software hosted on secure, ISO-certified cloud servers.
• Compliance with Regulations: Adherence to strict frameworks depending on your industry and geography.
• Regular Audits & Monitoring: Continuously monitoring, with frequent security audits to detect vulnerabilities and prevent unauthorized access or data leaks.
• Data Backup & Disaster Recovery: Scheduled backups and recovery plans, ensuring financial data can be restored quickly in case of cyberattacks or system failures.

Can an outsourced accounting service scale with a growing (or fluctuating) business?

Yes, they do. Scalability is one of the strongest benefits of accounting outsourcing services. If your transaction volume doubles, the provider can allocate additional accountants without you needing to hire, train, or manage them. Conversely, during slow months, you can scale back services without the fixed payroll burden.

Outsourced accounting firms typically offer tiered service models, starting with basic bookkeeping and extending to advanced financial planning, KPI tracking, and CFO-level strategic advisory. This flexibility ensures that as your business expands, whether by opening new locations, entering new markets, or managing seasonal spikes, your accounting services expand seamlessly.

How difficult is it to transition our bookkeeping to an outsourced firm?

Transitioning your bookkeeping to an outsourced firm may feel like a big step, but in practice, it’s a structured and manageable process. Depending on the state of your current records and the software you use, the transition usually includes data clean-up, software migration, access setup, and workflow design. Most businesses find the process much smoother than anticipated. Here’s what typically happens:

• Data cleanup: The process usually begins by correcting errors, reconciling accounts, and ensuring every entry is accurate and up to date. A clean starting point prevents issues from carrying over into the outsourced system.
• Software migration: This includes importing historical records, setting up integrations with banks and payment systems, and ensuring the new setup mirrors your reporting requirements.
• Access setup: Outsourced firms typically use bank-level encryption and multi-factor authentication. You’ll establish permissions for bank feeds, payroll systems, accounts payable portals, and any financial tools you use.
• Workflow design: Together, you’ll design clear workflows that match your business needs. For example: how invoices will be submitted, who approves payments, and how receipts and expenses claims are collected

Most firms provide an onboarding team to guide this process, often taking 2–8 weeks depending on the complexity. During this period, you benefit from close collaboration between your in-house team and the outsourced firm, ensuring a smooth and seamless transition with full accuracy and continuity.

How will we communicate and how often?

When choosing outsourced accounting in New York, one of the biggest concerns for business owners is losing visibility or control over financial operations. This risk is reduced when communication is structured and predictable. The reputed providers define a clear process from the start, set the frequency of check-ins, and make sure you always know how to reach the right person. To maintain transparency and control, accounting outsourcing providers usually offers:

• Weekly or bi-weekly check-ins during onboarding.
• Monthly review calls once operations stabilize.
• Ongoing access to Slack, Teams, Zoom, or client portals for quick updates
• Direct escalation contacts for urgent issues.

What does the accounting outsourcing process look like?

Outsourcing your accounting is a clear, step-by-step process, from assessing your needs and setting the plan to cleaning up data and setting up technology. With strong teamwork during onboarding, it culminates in accurate financial closing and continuous expert support. Here’s how it works:

• Assess Your Needs: This involves discussing goals, reporting requirements, and current pain points to tailor the services effectively.
• Proposal and Agreement: Based on the assessment, the provider prepares a customized proposal outlining service scope, deliverables, pricing, timelines, and communication protocols. Once agreed upon, a formal contract is signed.
• Data Clean-up: The provider reviews your existing financial data to correct any discrepancies, update charts of accounts, and perform necessary reconciliations, ensuring a clean starting point.
• Technology Setup: They set up or migrate accounting software and tools that best suit your business, ensuring integration for seamless transaction processing. Access rights and security protocols are established for secure collaboration.
• Onboarding and Collaboration: During this phase, your in-house team and the outsourced accounting provider collaborate closely to manage the transition. Regular check-ins, reporting, and open communication channels help avoid disruptions and maintain transparency.
• Transition and First Close: The outsourced team processes the initial accounting close, including journal entries and reconciliations. They then produce financial reports for review, addressing any questions or adjustments needed.
• Ongoing Support: Post-transition, the digital accountant handles continuous bookkeeping, payroll, accounts payable/receivable, tax support, and internal audits as needed.

Will the business have real-time access to its financial data?

Yes. Most accounting outsourcing providers use cloud platforms like QuickBooks, Xero, Zoho Books, or NetSuite, which give you real-time access to dashboards, profit and loss statements, balance sheets, and cash flow statements. Many firms build customized reporting dashboards that integrate with your bank and e-commerce systems for instant updates.

This real-time visibility supports faster decision-making, critical in NYC’s competitive business environment where cash flow and profitability decisions can’t wait until the month-end.

How often will the business receive financial reports?

Reporting schedules are flexible and tailored to your needs. The common monthly reports include profit and loss statements, balance sheets, and cash flow statements. Many firms also offer these reports:

• Weekly cash flow updates for businesses with high transaction volumes
• Quarterly performance reviews and forecasting
• Annual tax preparation and compliance reporting

Hire Dedicated Outsourced Accountant for your New York Business

Asking the right questions today saves you from costly mistakes tomorrow. A well-chosen outsourced accountant can transform accounting from a recurring task into a source of strategic value. For New York businesses facing tight competition and constant regulatory changes, that difference is what sustains long-term success.

At Whiz Consulting, we are your trusted partner for accounting outsourcing in New York, dedicated to simplifying accounting for businesses across the city. Our tailored accounting services cover everything from bookkeeping and payroll to complex needs like accounts payable/receivable, internal audit preparation, and tax support, ensuring complete compliance and clarity every step of the way.

Ready to get the right F&A solution? Connect with our team today to see what we can offer you!